Ombudsman's Decision Favors Claimants in Solar System Dispute

0

The affected homeowners were initially uncertain about what triggered the malfunction, which rendered their solar system inoperable. They speculated that a storm, coinciding with the onset of the problem, was the cause. They enlisted a solar expert's help, who discovered that a main fuse had blown, and the inverters were rendered ineffective due to component burnout.

The expert attributed the damage to an "external weather event," and repair estimates were pegged at $80,436. Conversely, an expert for the insurer, IAG, challenged this assessment by stating that no evidence of a storm impacting the property was found. IAG also dismissed the possibilities of a power surge or electrical distribution influence, asserting the damages likely arose from a generator failure.

Consequently, IAG refused the claim based on their policy, which excludes damages to electronic equipment due to electrical or mechanical malfunctions. Nonetheless, the claimants contended that their solar system shouldn't fall under the 'electronic equipment' category outlined in the policy.

In its assessment, the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) recognized the damages as "accidental damage." The authority agreed that while the system could be categorized as both electrical and electronic, the insurance policy included a clause that didn't cover electronic failures "unless the breakdown results in loss or damage to insured property."

AFCA criticized the insurer's stance that portrayed the solar system as a single unit without further collateral damage. The breakdown, starting with the fuse failure, didn't imply all involved systems were inherently linked as one unit. According to AFCA, the generator's issue led to ensuing property damage, leaving the entire solar inverter system and panels inoperative.

Although the ombudsman acknowledged the policy exclusion regarding the generator's main control fuse, they concluded the insurer must cover the remaining damages as they were resultant, and not only limited to the generator.

AFCA encouraged both parties to collaborate on resolving the claim, noting that the claimant's repair quote lacked itemization. IAG was advised to carry out its assessment and assure repairs with a lifetime guarantee. If the homeowners have already undertaken the repairs, the insurer is expected to reimburse their expenses.

Published:Friday, 23rd May 2025
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Clear

Rising Life Insurance Coverage Highlights Persistent Knowledge Gap 23 May 2025: Paige Estritori New findings from NobleOak reveal an upward trend in life insurance coverage among Australians, alongside a persistent gap in understanding of fully underwritten policies. According to the NobleOak Life Insurance Pulse Report, 60% of Australians aged 30 to 60 now hold life insurance, a noticeable increase from 55% the previous year. - read more

Ombudsman's Decision Favors Claimants in Solar System Dispute 23 May 2025: Paige Estritori Homeowners grappling with damaged solar power systems are set to have a substantial portion of their repair costs reimbursed. This follows a significant ruling where an ombudsman overruled the insurer IAG's application of an electronic malfunction exclusion in the claim process. - read more

AFCA Upholds Pause on QBE Claim but Dismisses Fraud Allegation 21 May 2025: Paige Estritori The Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) has ruled on a dispute involving insurer QBE and a vehicle damage claim. While QBE has been permitted to halt the processing of the claim until the policyholder, a company director, provides additional information, the fraud allegations levied against the claimant remain unsubstantiated. - read more

AFCA Upholds Policyholder's Claim, Dismisses Fraud Allegation in Car Theft Case 19 May 2025: Paige Estritori The Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) has dismissed allegations of fraud against a policyholder by Auto & General Services following an unsatisfactory investigation related to a stolen and burnt-out vehicle. The ruling in favour of the claimant highlights procedural gaps in the insurer’s investigation. - read more

Asgard Announces Significant Hike in Insurance Premiums 16 May 2025: Paige Estritori Asgard, the investment platform owned by Westpac, has announced substantial increases in insurance premium rates, ranging from 0.7% to 94.6%. This decision comes in collaboration with AIA Australia following a review of its insurance offerings. The changes, which will affect clients with Asgard Personal Protection Packages, are attributed to rising costs, including claims expenses. - read more