AFCA Upholds Policyholder's Claim, Dismisses Fraud Allegation in Car Theft Case

1

The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation, or needs. Consider seeking personal advice from a licensed adviser before acting on any information.

The case began when the claimant's car was stolen from a train station in September 2023. The police later recovered the burnt-out vehicle and apprehended a suspect with a history of vehicle thefts. Despite this, Auto & General Services rejected the claimant's coverage request, citing potential deceit. Their concerns centered on the claimant's financial struggles with overdue loan repayments and the insinuation that the theft might have been orchestrated.

The insurance company's investigation relied heavily on a forensic locksmith's assessment, suggesting the car was accessed using a legitimate key, as the car’s security features should have thwarted unauthorized entry. However, the locksmith found no evidence that the provided keys had duplicates. The insurer thus presumed the theft required a legitimate key, igniting suspicions of the claimant's involvement.

Despite these challenges, the claimant maintained his innocence, attributing his financial woes to his job loss after the theft, which had left him without the means to clear his vehicle loan. AFCA reviewed the evidence and contested the insurer's assertions, noting a lack of any proven connection between the claimant and the arrested thief.

AFCA criticized Auto & General's failure to allow the locksmith to examine the vehicle directly and questioned the conclusion that only a legitimate key could have been used in the theft. The investigation did not sufficiently justify its reliance on circumstantial reasoning without concrete evidence.

In its findings, AFCA determined there was no compelling evidence implicating the claimant in the theft or fraud. Consequently, Auto & General was instructed to honour the insurance claim and compensate the claimant with an additional $2000 for the distress caused by the delays and allegations.

This outcome raises significant concerns about the insurer's investigative procedures and evidentiary standards. AFCA noted Auto & General's dependence on conjecture without pursuing avenues that might have substantiated the claimant's account, indicating a need for insurers to rigorously substantiate fraud allegations before proceeding with denials.

The ruling underscores the importance of transparent and fair practices in the insurance industry, reminding insurers of their obligations to back assertions with clear evidence and address claims impartially.

Published:Monday, 19th May 2025
Source: Paige Estritori

Please Note: If this information affects you, seek advice from a licensed professional.

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Clear

APRA Implements Cap on High DTI Home Loans to Address Housing Market Concerns

13 Dec 2025: Paige Estritori

The Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) has announced a significant policy change aimed at mitigating risks in the housing market. Effective February 2026, APRA will impose a cap on high debt-to-income (DTI) home loans, limiting such loans to 20% of new home lending. This measure applies to both owner-occupiers and investors, with the exception of new housing developments. - read more

CHU's 2025 State of the Strata Market Report: Key Insights for Property Owners

13 Dec 2025: Paige Estritori

CHU, Australia's leading strata insurance underwriting agency, has released its 2025 State of the Strata Market report, providing a comprehensive analysis of current industry trends and challenges. The report indicates that strata insurance premiums have experienced a modest increase of 2.8% over the past year, rising from an average of $954 to $981 per lot annually. This growth rate is notably lower than the 3. - read more

NSW Fair Trading Proposes New Powers to Ensure Strata Property Maintenance

13 Dec 2025: Paige Estritori

The New South Wales (NSW) government has introduced a new tranche of strata reforms to parliament, aiming to enhance the maintenance and safety of apartment buildings across the state. A key component of these reforms is the proposal to grant NSW Fair Trading the authority to enter any apartment building without a warrant if there are reasonable grounds to believe that the owners corporation is failing to maintain common property adequately. - read more

ACCC Halts IAG's Acquisition of RAC Insurance Over Competition Concerns

11 Dec 2025: Paige Estritori

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) has recently blocked Insurance Australia Group's (IAG) proposed acquisition of RAC Insurance Pty Limited. This decision underscores the regulator's commitment to maintaining competitive dynamics within Western Australia's insurance market. - read more

Suncorp Reaches Maximum Reinsurance Retention Following Severe Storms in Queensland and NSW

11 Dec 2025: Paige Estritori

Recent supercell thunderstorms in South East Queensland and northern New South Wales have led to a surge in insurance claims, prompting Suncorp to reach its maximum reinsurance retention of $350 million. The insurer has reported over 10,000 claims related to these events, with approximately half pertaining to home damages and the other half to motor vehicles. - read more

Click for more Insurance News